Predicting construction project compliance with machine learning model: case study using Portuguese procurement data

• Type: Article in International Scientific Journal
• Date: 2024

Authors

Luís Jacques de Sousa (Author) FEUP; João Poças Martins (Author) FEUP; Luís Sanhudo (Author) Other

Journal

Title: Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management

Vol. 31 No. 13

Pages: 285-302

ISSN: 0969-9988

Publisher: Emerald

Indexing

ISI Web of Knowledge - 0 Citations

Scopus - 0 Citations

Other information

Authenticus ID: P-010-C6F

DOI: 10.1108/ecam-09-2023-0973

Abstract (EN): PurposeFactors like bid price, submission time, and number of bidders influence the procurement process in public projects. These factors and the award criteria may impact the project's financial compliance. Predicting budget compliance in construction projects has been traditionally challenging, but Machine Learning (ML) techniques have revolutionised estimations.Design/methodology/approachIn this study, Portuguese Public Procurement Data (PPPData) was utilised as the model's input. Notably, this dataset exhibited a substantial imbalance in the target feature. To address this issue, the study evaluated three distinct data balancing techniques: oversampling, undersampling, and the SMOTE method. Next, a comprehensive feature selection process was conducted, leading to the testing of five different algorithms for forecasting budget compliance. Finally, a secondary test was conducted, refining the features to include only those elements that procurement technicians can modify while also considering the two most accurate predictors identified in the previous test.FindingsThe findings indicate that employing the SMOTE method on the scraped data can achieve a balanced dataset. Furthermore, the results demonstrate that the Adam ANN algorithm outperformed others, boasting a precision rate of 68.1%.Practical implicationsThe model can aid procurement technicians during the tendering phase by using historical data and analogous projects to predict performance.Social implicationsAlthough the study reveals that ML algorithms cannot accurately predict budget compliance using procurement data, they can still provide project owners with insights into the most suitable criteria, aiding decision-making. Further research should assess the model's impact and capacity within the procurement workflow.Originality/valuePrevious research predominantly focused on forecasting budgets by leveraging data from the private construction execution phase. While some investigations incorporated procurement data, this study distinguishes itself by using an imbalanced dataset and anticipating compliance rather than predicting budgetary figures. The model predicts budget compliance by analysing qualitative and quantitative characteristics of public project contracts. The research paper explores various model architectures and data treatment techniques to develop a model to assist the Client in tender definition.

Language: English

Type (Professor's evaluation): Scientific

No. of pages: 18